Skip to main content

Finding the Right Color Mascara


a woman is brushing her teeth in front of a mirrorfour assorted-color mascaras

Finding a mascara color can be a big task. And if you take care of a family, are a caregiver, work a 9 to 5 job, are in school, or you just don't have a lot of spare time throughout your day - standing in front of the mascara wall in a drugstore or at the beauty counter in a department store isn’t anything you want to do. 


When most of us think mascara, we think black. But the truth is, the right mascara color can elevate your whole look depending on your vibe, your features, and what you’re going for that day. Here are a few tips to help you pick the shade that fits you best:



1. Start With Your Natural Features

 

  • Hair color, eye color, and skin tone all play a role. Here's a quick cheat sheet:
    • Dark brown or black hair + brown or deep eyes: Black or blackest black will give you definition and drama without looking too harsh.
    • Lighter brown or hazel eyes: Try brown-black or deep plum to enhance your eye color without overdoing it.
    • Lighter skin + light eyes (blue, green, grey): Soft black or brown mascara can give you that natural pop without looking too bold.

2. Think About the Look You’re Going For

 

  • Everyday natural look? Go with brown or brown-black. It’s soft and pretty, and still gives your lashes a little something something.
  • Night out or full-glam moment? Go bold with blackest black. She’s classic, she’s confident, and she shows up in pictures.
  • Want to have fun? Colored mascaras like navy, burgundy, or emerald can make your eye color pop—especially if you're going minimal on the rest of your makeup.

3. Try It Out and See What Works

 

Don’t be afraid to experiment. What looks “natural” or “too bold” is different for everybody. Try different shades and see how you feel. Sometimes brown mascara can surprise you and it might be just the soft vibe you didn’t know you needed.


4. Don’t Forget Your Lower Lashes

 

If you’re someone who likes to play it subtle on the bottom lashes, a brown or soft black can help define without overpowering. It’s a cute trick to keep things balanced, especially if you’re wearing a bold upper lash line.


5. Use Your Skin Tone as a Guide

 

For deeper skin tones:

  • Blackest black and deep plum can be especially flattering.
  • Lighter browns may not show up well, so look for rich, pigmented formulas if you're experimenting.

For lighter skin tones:

  • Brown or brown-black might be your go-to for a soft, everyday look.

Final Tip: Let the Mirror Be Your Guide

 

At the end of the day, makeup isn’t about following strict rules. It’s about what makes you feel good when you look in the mirror. If it makes you smile and feel confident, that’s the right shade for you. So have fun trying new things, and don’t be afraid to switch it up whenever you want.

 

If you’ve got a favorite mascara color or some tips of your own, drop a comment below. I’d love to hear what works for you!



-XO

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

My New Journey as a Bomb Party Rep

  At this age, I’m not letting fear or anyone else’s opinions hold me back. I’ve loved jewelry and all things that sparkle since I was a little girl. I've also loved jewelry, accessories, clothes, shoes, purses - all the things we all love, right!?!?!  Recently, I decided to start a new chapter as a  Bomb Party Representative . My official launch is November 1, 2025 and this is completely new to me. In many ways, it feels like coming home to something I’ve always loved - jewelry, fun and community. I also get to sell one of my favorite jewelry lines that I actually wear every day.  ✨ Starting Again with Intention Over the years, I’ve started and stopped plenty of business ventures and direct sales opportunities. Most of those didn’t work out - not because they couldn’t, but because I wasn’t ready. I didn’t always have the confidence, discipline, or marketing know-how I needed to really be successful. But this time feels different. Right now, I’m in a season where I’m...

This Chapter of Womanhood: Embracing the Now

Not too long ago, I shared some thoughts about starting over . I’ve come to truly appreciate how often we as women have the power to stop, shift, and begin again throughout our life. It may not always feel like we have those choices, especially when life is heavy or resources are tight; but even then I’ve learned that the option to “start again” or to pivot is always on the table. It might take some planning, a new strategy, or help from others, but it’s still there.  One thing I’ve always stood on both in life and on social media is this: if you want to start over or be someone different, you can and should do it - unapologetically. But  what if you want to start over so you can be who you used to be? What if you feel stuck or unhappy with who you are now and you want to get back to that girl or woman you used to know? What if you have been unable to start over or begin something new because you just can’t quite be who you used to be? She always did it; but you now, you’re h...

She Is Becoming: Faith, Purpose, and the Freedom to Keep Going

I like shiny things and have always liked shiny things. I’m a woman who loves jewelry that sparkles, all types of hair styles, long nails, short nails, glossy lips, and clothes that make me feel good at any size. Some days my personality shines; other days the jewelry does more. Either way, it’s me, and I love it. I’ve also found my people—women who mirror this energy and remind me to embrace who I am while tuning out outside criticism and insecurity. This season of my life truly has given me the renewal of 'self' that I needed and more things that I didn't even know I need.  I’m still figuring it all out (and pivoting along way) but at 43 here's what God has already created paths for and seeds I am (or will be) harvesting in the future: A company that celebrates women and womanhood in many forms A beauty and lifestyle platform that connects women to things that bring them joy and wellness A writing journey that brings fantasy and day dreams onto the page Rebuilding my ...